Jersey Mike’s 13 Secret Menu Item With Prices in 2025

Want to know what tasty and unique sandwiches are on the Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu? This menu is full of hidden subs and special creations that sandwich lovers will enjoy.

In this guide, you’ll learn about popular secret items like the #99 Steak, Surf ‘n’ Turf, and Pepperoni Pizza Sub, plus other custom hacks and rare flavors.

Whether you’re looking for something spicy, creative, or completely off-menu, you’ll find tips on how to order and customize your sub. Discover one-of-a-kind sandwiches only insiders know about, explained in simple, clear language so you can enjoy your next Jersey Mike’s meal to the fullest.

[forminator_poll id=”536″]

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Cold Subs

Jersey Mike’s Cold Subs are made fresh to order with quality meats, cheeses, and toppings, served on soft bread. Popular options include Turkey & Provolone, The Original Italian, and Ham & Provolone. You can enjoy them “Mike’s Way” with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, vinegar, and spices for extra flavor.

1. Surf ‘n’ Turf

The “Surf ‘n’ Turf” is a Jersey Mike’s secret menu sub made by customizing the #9 Club Supreme. Normally, the #9 Club Supreme has roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, bacon, and mayonnaise. To make the Surf ‘n’ Turf, you ask for the #9 but swap the turkey for tuna, remove the bacon, and change the Swiss cheese to provolone.

This creates a unique sub with roast beef, tuna, provolone cheese, and your choice of toppings. Since it’s a custom order, the price, calories, and nutrition details can vary by location and the changes you make. The information here is based on a regular-size sub on white bread, without extra condiments, unless noted.

2. The Martian

“The Martian” is a Jersey Mike’s secret menu sub that’s not part of the regular menu. It’s known for its bold, spicy flavor, made by combining several Italian meats. To order it, start with the #5 Super Sub and ask to swap the ham for salami and the prosciutto for pepperoni.

This creates a hearty sandwich with salami, pepperoni, capicola, and provolone cheese—an all-red-meat, spicy treat. Since it’s a custom order, the price and nutrition details aren’t listed on the standard menu.

Estimates are based on a regular-size sub on white bread without extra toppings, but the final numbers will depend on your location and any add-ons.

3. Cuban Supreme

The “Cuban Supreme” is a Jersey Mike’s secret menu sandwich inspired by the classic Cuban sandwich. It’s not on the regular menu, but you can order it by starting with the #5 Super Sub and making a few changes. Instead of provolone, ask for Swiss cheese, then add pickles and spicy mustard. Some versions also replace the prosciuttini with salami.

The result is a flavorful sub with ham, cappacuolo, and Swiss cheese, balanced by the tangy taste of pickles and spicy mustard. Since it’s a custom creation, the price and nutrition details aren’t listed on the official menu. Estimates are based on a regular-size sub on white bread without extra condiments unless mentioned.

4. Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub

Jersey Mike’s doesn’t have a “Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub” on its official menu, but it does offer a similar hot sub called the Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak. You can also make a cold version by customizing the #8 Club Sub.

The #8 already comes with turkey, bacon, and provolone, so you just ask to replace the mayonnaise with ranch dressing. Below is information for both the official Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak and the custom Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub, based on a regular-size sub on white bread.

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Hot Subs

Jersey Mike’s Hot Subs are grilled-to-order sandwiches served warm with freshly cooked meats, melted cheese, and flavorful toppings. Popular choices include the Famous Philly, Chicken Philly, and Chipotle Cheese Steak, each made on soft bread and packed with hearty, savory flavors.

5. Big Kahuna Cheese Steak With Chipotle Mayo

The “Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo” is a Jersey Mike’s secret menu favorite that mixes two official subs—the #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak and the #43 Chipotle Cheese Steak.

To get it, order the #56 and ask for chipotle mayonnaise to be added. The Big Kahuna normally includes grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, extra white American cheese, and beef steak.

Adding chipotle mayo gives it a smoky, spicy flavor with a rich, savory taste. Since it’s a custom creation, the price and nutrition details aren’t listed on the regular menu. Estimates are based on a regular-size sub on white bread without extra toppings, but the final numbers can vary by location and how much chipotle mayo is used.

6. The Chick-Fila-Roni

The “Chick-Fila-Roni” is a Jersey Mike’s secret menu sub that puts a spicy twist on the classic Philly cheesesteak. Instead of steak, it uses grilled chicken and adds pepperoni for extra flavor. To order it, ask for a #17 Mike’s Famous Philly but replace the steak with chicken and add pepperoni.

You’ll get a hot sub with grilled onions, peppers, Swiss cheese, chicken, and spicy pepperoni. The name is a fun nod to a famous fast-food chain and the pepperoni topping. Since it’s a custom creation, the price and nutrition details aren’t on the official menu, and they can vary depending on location and extras.

7. Pepperoni Pizza Sub

The Pepperoni Pizza Sub is a well-known secret menu item at Jersey Mike’s, created to taste like a pepperoni pizza in a sub roll. It’s not part of the official menu, so you’ll need to customize your order. A common way to get it is to start with a #3 The American Classic, replace the ham with pepperoni, add marinara sauce, and request extra provolone cheese.

Ask for it to be grilled or toasted for the best flavor. Some people also add oregano and parmesan cheese for more of a pizza taste. Since it’s a custom sandwich, it won’t have official nutrition or price details, but estimates are available for a regular-sized version on white bread with no extra toppings.

8. Cafeteria Classic

The “Cafeteria Classic” is a popular Jersey Mike’s secret menu item, inspired by the simple ham and cheese sandwiches often served in school cafeterias. It’s a twist on the #3 Ham and Provolone sub, made by asking for no “Juice” (olive oil and vinegar), no onions or vegetables, and adding mayonnaise instead.

This creates a plain but tasty sandwich with just ham, provolone cheese, and mayo on fresh bread. Since it’s a custom order, it’s not listed on the official menu, and the exact price or nutrition info may vary.

9. Buffalo Chicken Sub

The Buffalo Chicken Sub at Jersey Mike’s, also called the #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak, is a hot and spicy favorite. It’s made with grilled chicken cooked in Frank’s RedHot® sauce, topped with melted white American cheese, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and creamy blue cheese dressing.

This mix of spicy and tangy flavors makes it a top choice for buffalo-style food lovers. The details below are for a regular-sized sub on white bread, but prices and nutrition may vary by location.

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Salads and Vegetarian Options

Jersey Mike’s Salads and Vegetarian Options include fresh, made-to-order salads like the Garden Salad and customizable options with your choice of veggies, cheese, and dressings. Vegetarian choices also feature subs like the Veggie, packed with provolone, Swiss, and green bell peppers, plus “Mike’s Way” toppings for extra flavor.

10. Sub in a Tub

The “Sub in a Tub” is a low-carb, gluten-free, and keto-friendly way to enjoy any Jersey Mike’s sub without the bread. Instead of being served on a roll, all the meats, cheeses, and toppings are chopped and placed in a bowl.

This option is great for anyone who wants the full flavor of a Jersey Mike’s sandwich while avoiding carbs and gluten. You can order almost any cold or hot sub this way, except for items like meatballs or breaded chicken that contain wheat.

The price is the same as the regular-size sub you choose. Since a “Sub in a Tub” can be made from any menu item, the nutrition, calories, and allergens will vary based on your selection.

11. Sweet Pepper Wrap

The Sweet Pepper Wrap is a Jersey Mike’s secret menu item, meaning it’s not on the official menu. It’s a tasty and lighter alternative to a regular sub. To order it, ask for a grilled veggie wrap and customize it.

A popular version includes grilled bell peppers and onions, cherry pepper relish instead of ranch, chipotle mayo for a smoky and spicy flavor, and provolone cheese.

Since this is a custom order, the price, calories, and nutrition details aren’t listed on the official menu. The table below shows estimated information for a regular wrap, but the final numbers may change depending on your location and the ingredients you choose.

12. Lumberjack Salad

The “Lumberjack Salad” is not an official Jersey Mike’s menu item. It’s a popular secret menu choice and a twist on their “Sub in a Tub,” where all the sandwich ingredients are served in a bowl without bread.

This makes it a lower-carb and keto-friendly option. To order it, ask for a #9 Club Supreme “in a tub” (as a salad). The #9 Club Supreme includes roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, and bacon, and some versions also add ham for extra protein. It’s a hearty, meat-heavy salad perfect for meat lovers. Prices and nutrition can vary depending on location and any dressing you add.

13. Avocado Veggie Sub

The “Avocado Veggie Sub” is not an official menu item at Jersey Mike’s, but you can make it by customizing the #14 The Veggie. The regular Veggie sub includes provolone, Swiss cheese, and green bell peppers.

To turn it into an Avocado Veggie Sub, simply add fresh avocado as an extra topping. Many people also order it “Mike’s Way”, which means adding lettuce, tomatoes, onions, olive oil, red wine vinegar, and spices.

Since this is a custom order, the price and nutrition details may vary. The estimates below are based on a regular-sized sub on white bread with avocado.

Jersey Mike Secret Menu Review Video

How To Order Your Favorite?

Ordering In-Store: The classic and most popular way to order. Simply walk in, choose your sub, and watch it being made fresh in an efficient “assembly line” style.

Ordering Online or Through the App: Perfect for saving time and skipping the line. Place your order ahead for quick pickup or convenient delivery.

Ordering Catering: Ideal for parties, meetings, or events. Jersey Mike’s catering can be ordered online or by contacting your nearest store directly.

Customer Service

FAQs